When Your Child Struggles With Gratitude: Understanding Different Ways Children Express Appreciation
As the holiday season approaches, many families begin thinking about traditions, gift-giving, family gatherings, and opportunities to spend time together. Along with these celebrations often come expectations about gratitude. Children are encouraged to say “thank you,” express excitement when opening presents, write thank-you notes, and show appreciation when someone does something kind for them. For many children, these expectations feel relatively straightforward. However, for some neurodivergent children, expressing gratitude in the ways adults expect can be surprisingly difficult. A child might receive a thoughtful gift but show very little excitement. Another might become upset because the present is not what they expected. Some children forget to say thank you, struggle to write thank-you notes, or have difficulty responding when someone gives them something. Others may seem more interested in the details of the gift than in acknowledging the person who gave it.

These reactions can sometimes be misunderstood as being ungrateful, selfish, entitled, or poorly behaved. Parents may feel embarrassed when their child does not respond as expected, particularly in front of extended family members. They may also worry that their child is not learning important social skills or developing an appreciation for what others do for them. However, it is important to recognize that expressing gratitude and experiencing gratitude are not necessarily the same thing. A child may genuinely appreciate something without knowing how to communicate that appreciation in a socially expected way.
For neurodivergent children, differences in communication, emotional expression, sensory processing, attention, and executive functioning can all influence how gratitude is experienced and demonstrated. Understanding these differences can help parents teach gratitude in ways that are meaningful, supportive, and developmentally appropriate without making children feel that their natural responses are wrong.
What Does Gratitude Actually Mean?
Gratitude is often described as recognizing and appreciating something positive that another person has done or provided. It can involve recognizing kindness, feeling thankful, acknowledging support, and understanding that someone has made an effort on our behalf. Although gratitude may seem like a simple social behavior, it involves several different skills. For example, when a child receives a birthday present, expressing gratitude may involve:
Recognizing that someone selected or purchased something specifically for them.
Understanding that the other person intended to do something kind.
Processing the experience of receiving something unexpected.
Identifying and interpreting their own emotional response.
Understanding the social expectation to acknowledge the gift.
Finding the words or actions to communicate appreciation.
Remembering to follow through with an appropriate response.
These steps involve much more than simply saying “thank you.” For some children, especially those with differences in executive functioning, social communication, emotional regulation, or sensory processing, one or more of these steps may be challenging. It is also important to remember that gratitude develops over time. Young children are still learning to recognize other people's intentions, understand social expectations, and consider perspectives beyond their own. Even older children may need support understanding that someone can demonstrate kindness in ways that are not immediately obvious to them.
Rather than assuming that a child who does not express gratitude is unappreciative, parents can consider what skills may be involved in the situation and whether the child has the tools needed to communicate what they are feeling.
Why Gratitude Can Be Difficult for Neurodivergent Children
There is no single explanation for why a neurodivergent child might struggle to express gratitude. Different developmental profiles can influence how children process social situations, respond emotionally, and communicate appreciation.
Understanding some of these differences can help parents respond more effectively.
1. Executive Functioning Differences Can Make Expressing Gratitude Difficult
Executive functioning refers to the mental processes that help us manage our thoughts, emotions, and behaviors in order to accomplish tasks. These skills include working memory, inhibition, planning, organization, cognitive flexibility, and self-monitoring. Many children with ADHD experience differences in executive functioning. These differences can affect everyday social expectations, including expressing gratitude. For example, a child might genuinely appreciate receiving a gift but forget to say thank you. They may become distracted by opening the next present, start playing with the toy, or move on to another activity before remembering to acknowledge the person who gave it to them.
This does not necessarily mean the child is being inconsiderate. Remembering to pause, recognize the social expectation, and respond appropriately requires several executive functioning skills.
Other examples include:
Working memory: A child may forget to say thank you even when they understand that it is expected.
Inhibitory control: A child may have difficulty stopping an exciting activity long enough to acknowledge someone.
Cognitive flexibility: A child may struggle when a gift is unexpected or different from what they anticipated.
Self-monitoring: A child may not recognize how their response is being interpreted by others.
Task initiation: A child may have difficulty getting started on writing thank-you notes, even when they intend to complete them.
Parents may find it helpful to separate the child's understanding of gratitude from their ability to consistently demonstrate it. A child who needs reminders, visual prompts, or help completing a thank-you note may understand and appreciate the kindness involved. They may simply need support with the executive functioning demands of expressing it.
2. Social Communication Differences Can Affect How Gratitude Is Expressed
For autistic children, social communication differences may influence how they understand and respond to expectations around gratitude. Many social interactions involve unwritten rules. People are often expected to respond in particular ways even when those expectations have not been explicitly explained.
For example, when receiving a gift, a child may be expected to:
Look at the person giving the gift.
Smile or show excitement.
Say something positive about the present.
Express appreciation.
Demonstrate an appropriate level of enthusiasm.
However, these expectations are not necessarily intuitive for every child.
An autistic child may understand that someone gave them a gift but may not recognize all the social expectations associated with receiving it. They may not naturally understand why they are expected to show excitement, make eye contact, or immediately comment on the gift. Some children may communicate appreciation in ways that look different from traditional social responses. They might carefully examine the gift, ask detailed questions about how it works, or begin talking about a related interest. Others may show appreciation later by using the gift frequently or sharing information about it with the person who gave it to them. For example, a child who receives a science kit may immediately begin explaining all the experiments they want to complete. Rather than saying, "Thank you! I love it!" they may demonstrate their interest by enthusiastically discussing the possibilities. Their response may reflect genuine excitement and appreciation, even if it does not match what an adult expected.
Parents can help children understand social expectations while also recognizing that there is more than one appropriate way to demonstrate appreciation.
3. Sensory Processing Differences Can Interfere With Emotional Responses
Gift-giving and holiday celebrations often involve a significant amount of sensory stimulation. Bright lights, loud conversations, unfamiliar smells, crowded rooms, music, wrapping paper, and unexpected changes can create an overwhelming environment for children with sensory sensitivities. A child who is already managing sensory overload may have very little capacity left to respond to social expectations. Imagine a child opening presents at a large family gathering. There are several conversations happening at once, younger cousins are running around, people are taking pictures, and relatives are watching closely to see the child's reaction. Even if the child is excited about the gift, the surrounding sensory demands may make it difficult to process the experience. They might:
Become quiet or withdrawn.
Appear uninterested.
Become frustrated or upset.
Focus on one specific aspect of the environment.
Want to leave the room.
Have difficulty responding to questions or expressing emotions.
In these situations, the child's response may have very little to do with how much they appreciate the gift. Sensory overload can make it difficult to communicate, regulate emotions, and participate in social interactions. Parents may need to prioritize helping their child feel comfortable and regulated before expecting them to demonstrate gratitude.
4. Emotional Regulation Differences Can Affect Responses to Gifts and Kindness
Receiving a gift is often an emotionally charged experience. Children may feel excitement, anticipation, surprise, disappointment, confusion, or even anxiety.
For children who experience emotional regulation differences, managing these feelings can be challenging. A child with ADHD, for example, may experience intense excitement when receiving something they have been anticipating. Their emotional response may be so strong that they struggle to pause and acknowledge the person who gave them the gift. Other children may become upset if a present does not match what they expected. They may have imagined receiving a particular item and find it difficult to shift their expectations when something different is presented. This can be particularly challenging for children who experience differences in cognitive flexibility, or the ability to adjust thinking and behavior when circumstances change. A child might respond by saying, "I didn't want this," or "This isn't what I asked for." Although this response may feel hurtful to the person giving the gift, it does not necessarily mean the child is intentionally rejecting their kindness. The child may be struggling to manage disappointment, communicate unexpected feelings, or shift away from a strongly anticipated outcome. Parents can acknowledge the child's feelings while still teaching them how to respond respectfully. For example: "I can see that you were really hoping for the other game. It's okay to feel disappointed. Your aunt picked this out because she wanted to do something special for you. We can talk about how to let her know we appreciate the thought." This approach communicates two important messages: feelings are allowed, and we can learn to consider other people's feelings when deciding how to respond.
5. Differences in Perspective-Taking May Influence How Children Understand Kindness
Perspective-taking involves recognizing that other people have their own thoughts, feelings, intentions, and experiences. Some neurodivergent children may need more explicit support understanding the perspectives of others. This does not mean they lack empathy or do not care about other people. In fact, many neurodivergent children experience strong empathy but may express it differently or have difficulty interpreting what another person expects from them.
For example, a child might not immediately recognize that a grandparent spent time choosing a gift or that a sibling put considerable effort into making something special. They may focus on their own experience of receiving the item without automatically considering the intentions behind it. Parents can help make these connections more concrete. Instead of simply saying, "You should be grateful," try explaining: "Grandma remembered that you like building things. She looked for something she thought you would enjoy because she wanted to make you happy." This gives the child specific information about the other person's actions and intentions. Over time, children can develop a deeper understanding of how kindness is communicated and how their responses affect other people.
When a Child's Reaction Doesn't Match What Adults Expect
One of the most challenging parts of teaching gratitude can be navigating the difference between a child's actual response and what adults expect to see.
Adults often associate gratitude with visible enthusiasm, polite language, eye contact, and immediate acknowledgment. However, children do not all express emotions in the same way. Consider a few common situations.
The child who does not appear excited about a gift.
A child may be happy to receive a present but show little outward emotion. They might have a more neutral facial expression, need time to process the experience, or express excitement privately rather than in front of others.
The child who immediately focuses on what is wrong.
A child might notice that a gift is missing a particular feature or does not work the way they expected. This may reflect attention to detail, difficulty with flexibility, or disappointment rather than a lack of appreciation.
The child who forgets to say thank you.
A child may become absorbed in the activity or distracted by something else. They may need a prompt to remember the social expectation.
The child who prefers a practical response.
Rather than saying, "I love this!" a child may show appreciation by using the gift regularly, asking the giver to participate, or sharing what they have learned from it.
The child who becomes overwhelmed by attention.
Some children find it uncomfortable to have others watching them open presents or waiting for a particular reaction. They may become quiet, avoid eye contact, or want to leave the situation.
These examples illustrate why it is important to avoid using a child's immediate reaction as the only measure of whether they feel appreciative. A more useful question is: What might this child's response be communicating, and what support would help them express themselves?
Teaching Gratitude Without Forcing a Particular Emotional Response
Parents understandably want their children to develop gratitude. Recognizing kindness, appreciating other people, and responding respectfully are important social and relationship skills. However, teaching gratitude does not require children to perform emotions they are not experiencing or demonstrate appreciation in one specific way. The goal is to help children understand gratitude, recognize kindness, and develop ways to communicate appreciation that feel authentic and respectful. Here are several strategies parents can use.
1. Separate Feeling Grateful From Saying Thank You
Help children understand that gratitude is more than a phrase.
Saying "thank you" is one way to communicate appreciation, but it is not the same thing as experiencing it. You can explain: "Gratitude means recognizing when someone does something kind or helpful. Saying thank you is one way we let them know we noticed." This distinction helps children understand the purpose behind the social expectation. It also gives parents an opportunity to discuss different ways of showing appreciation, such as sharing, helping, spending time together, or taking care of something someone has given them.
2. Teach Social Expectations Explicitly
Some children benefit from direct explanations of social expectations rather than being expected to figure them out through observation. For example, parents can explain: "When someone gives you a present, they usually want to know that you received it and recognize that they thought of you. You can say thank you, tell them something you like about it, or ask them a question about it." You can also practice different situations at home through role-play. For example:
Someone gives you a present you really like.
Someone gives you something unexpected.
Someone helps you with a difficult task.
Someone makes something for you.
Someone invites you to participate in an activity.
Discuss what the child might say or do in each situation. The goal is not to create a rigid set of social rules. It is to provide children with practical communication tools they can use when they are unsure how to respond.
3. Offer Multiple Ways to Express Appreciation
Not every child is comfortable expressing gratitude verbally or immediately.
Consider offering different options:
Saying "thank you."
Writing a short note.
Drawing a picture.
Sending a message.
Giving the person a hug, if the child wants to.
Asking the person to play with or participate in the activity.
Showing the person how much they enjoy using the gift.
Sharing something positive about the experience later.
For children who struggle with verbal communication, these alternatives can be particularly helpful. Importantly, physical affection should not be required as a demonstration of gratitude. A child should not have to hug or kiss someone simply because that person gave them a gift. Teaching appreciation should not come at the expense of bodily autonomy.
4. Give Children Time to Process Their Feelings
Not every child can immediately identify or communicate how they feel.
Some children need additional time to process an unexpected experience, regulate their emotions, or decide how they want to respond. If your child does not immediately express appreciation, consider allowing them to respond later.
For example, if a child receives a gift at a family gathering and becomes overwhelmed, they might write a note the next day or tell the person about the gift after they have had time to explore it. This approach allows the child to communicate appreciation without placing unnecessary pressure on them in the moment.
5. Use Specific Language Instead of General Reminders
Statements such as "Be grateful" or "You should appreciate what you have" may not provide enough information for a child who struggles with understanding social expectations or emotional awareness. Instead, use concrete language that explains what happened and why it matters.
For example:
"Your brother shared his favorite toy with you because he wanted you to have fun."
"Dad spent time helping you build that. He enjoyed doing it with you."
"Your teacher noticed you were having a difficult day and found a way to help."
"Aunt Sarah remembered that you enjoy drawing and picked out something she thought you would like."
These explanations help children connect another person's actions with the experience of receiving kindness.
6. Support Executive Functioning When Gratitude Requires Follow-Through
Some expressions of gratitude involve tasks that require planning, organization, working memory, and task initiation. Writing thank-you notes is a good example.
A child may want to thank relatives for gifts but struggle with remembering who gave what, organizing their thoughts, getting started, and completing the notes.
Parents can reduce these demands by providing structure. For example:
Keep a simple list of who gave each gift.
Take pictures of gifts and label them with the giver's name.
Provide a short thank-you note template.
Break the task into smaller steps.
Complete a few notes at a time rather than expecting the child to finish everything at once.
Offer assistance with writing or spelling when needed.
A simple note might include: "Thank you for the art supplies. I like using the markers to draw pictures." For younger children, parents can help write the message while the child contributes an idea, drawing, or signature. The purpose is to help children participate in meaningful expressions of appreciation, not to make the process unnecessarily difficult.
7. Model Gratitude in Everyday Situations
Children learn a great deal about gratitude by observing the adults around them.
Parents can model appreciation in everyday interactions, including situations that have nothing to do with gifts. For example:
"Thank you for helping me carry those bags."
"I appreciate that you waited while I finished my phone call."
"It was kind of your brother to share his snack."
"I really enjoyed spending time with you today."
You can also talk about appreciation without requiring a particular response from your child. For example, after someone helps your family, you might say:
"That was really thoughtful of our neighbor. It made things easier for us."
These everyday examples help children recognize kindness as something that happens regularly, rather than something they are only expected to acknowledge during holidays or special occasions.
8. Avoid Comparing Your Child's Reactions to Other Children's Reactions
It can be tempting to point out when another child responds differently.
For example, saying, "Look how excited your cousin was when she opened her present," may seem like a way to encourage a more appropriate response.
However, comparisons can create shame and communicate that there is only one acceptable way to experience or express emotions. Instead, focus on helping your child understand the specific expectations of a situation and develop skills that support their individual communication style. A child does not need to look excited, make eye contact, or display a particular facial expression to be appreciative. The emphasis should be on respectful communication and understanding, not performing emotions for other people.
What If Your Child Says Something Hurtful When Receiving a Gift?
Even when parents understand the role of neurodivergence, it can still be difficult when a child makes a comment that hurts someone's feelings. For example:
"I don't like this."
"I wanted something else."
"Why did you get me this?"
"This isn't what I asked for."
It is important to recognize that understanding a child's developmental differences does not mean ignoring the impact of their words. Children can learn that their feelings are valid while also learning how to communicate those feelings respectfully. A helpful response might be: "I understand that you were hoping for something different. It's okay to feel disappointed. When someone gives you a gift, we want to think about their feelings, too. You can say, 'Thank you for thinking of me,' even if the gift wasn't what you expected." If the child is already overwhelmed, it may be more effective to wait until they are calm before discussing what happened. Parents can also help children practice alternative phrases:
"Thank you for getting this for me."
"I wasn't expecting this."
"Can you show me how it works?"
"I need a little time to look at it."
"Thank you for thinking of me."
These phrases give children options for responding honestly without being unnecessarily hurtful. The goal is not to teach children to pretend they love everything they receive. It is to help them communicate their feelings while considering the intentions and feelings of others.
Helping Extended Family Members Understand Your Child's Responses
Holiday gatherings can be particularly challenging when extended family members have different expectations about how children should behave.
A relative may interpret a child's limited reaction to a present as disappointment or disrespect. Someone else may expect a hug, eye contact, or an enthusiastic thank-you. Parents may feel caught between supporting their child and managing other adults' reactions. It can help to provide some context before a gathering. For example, parents might explain:
"Our child sometimes needs extra time to process surprises and may not show excitement right away. That doesn't mean they aren't happy to see you or that they don't appreciate the gift."
Other helpful explanations might include:
"They may need a quiet place to take a break if things get overwhelming."
"They are still learning how to respond in social situations, so we may give them reminders."
"They may show you how much they like a gift later by playing with it or talking about it."
"We are working on helping them express appreciation in ways that feel comfortable and genuine."
Parents do not need to disclose every detail about their child's diagnosis or developmental profile. A brief explanation can often help relatives understand that a child's response may look different without implying that the child is being intentionally rude. It is also important to remember that parents are not responsible for making every relative understand or agree with their child's needs. Their primary responsibility is to support their child while teaching appropriate and respectful communication.
Gratitude Should Be About Connection, Not Compliance
One of the most important things parents can remember is that gratitude should not become another area where children feel pressure to perform.
When children are repeatedly told to smile, look at someone, act excited, or say the expected words, they may begin to associate gratitude with avoiding criticism rather than recognizing kindness. For some neurodivergent children, this pressure can contribute to masking: the process of consciously or unconsciously suppressing natural responses or changing behavior to meet perceived social expectations.
Children may learn to perform an expected reaction even when they feel uncomfortable, confused, or overwhelmed. Although learning social communication skills is valuable, children should also be allowed to express themselves authentically. A child who quietly says thank you, writes a note later, or spends hours enjoying a thoughtful gift may be expressing appreciation just as meaningfully as a child who immediately responds with excitement.
Parents can teach gratitude while also communicating that their child's feelings, communication style, and sensory needs matter. This balance helps children develop genuine social understanding rather than simply learning to follow rules.
When to Consider Additional Support
If your child consistently struggles with social communication, emotional regulation, flexibility, or executive functioning, it may be helpful to explore whether these challenges are connected to their broader developmental profile.
For example, a child who frequently forgets social expectations may benefit from understanding their executive functioning skills. A child who struggles to interpret social situations may benefit from exploring their social communication development. A child who becomes overwhelmed during celebrations may have sensory processing differences that affect participation. A comprehensive psychoeducational or psychological evaluation can help identify patterns of strengths and differences across areas such as:
Attention and executive functioning.
Social communication and interaction.
Cognitive flexibility.
Emotional and behavioral regulation.
Language and communication.
Sensory experiences and related functional concerns.
Learning and adaptive skills.
Understanding these areas can help parents recognize why certain situations are challenging and identify strategies that support their child's development.
It is important to remember that difficulty expressing gratitude by itself does not indicate ADHD, autism, or another developmental difference. Many factors influence how children respond to social expectations, and concerns should be considered within the broader context of a child's development and daily functioning.
Helping Children Develop Genuine Appreciation
Gratitude is an important skill, but it does not develop through reminders to say thank you alone. Children learn to appreciate others through relationships, everyday experiences, modeling, explicit teaching, and opportunities to recognize kindness. For neurodivergent children, the process may look different. They may need additional time to process emotions, more explicit explanations of social expectations, support with executive functioning, or alternative ways to communicate appreciation. Rather than focusing exclusively on whether a child demonstrates gratitude in the expected way, parents can look for the many ways their child recognizes and responds to kindness. Perhaps your child remembers something a family member taught them, enjoys using a gift long after the holiday has passed, offers to help someone, or shares an interest with a person they care about. These actions may communicate appreciation even when traditional expressions of gratitude do not come naturally.
Ultimately, the goal is not to raise children who simply know when to say "thank you." It is to help them understand kindness, recognize the contributions of others, and develop meaningful ways to communicate appreciation. When parents approach gratitude with patience, flexibility, and an understanding of neurodivergent development, they create opportunities for children to build genuine connections while remaining true to who they are. Gratitude does not have to look the same for every child to be meaningful.
ADHD - Autism - Executive Functioning - Learning Disorders


Comments